Somewhere along the way, I lost the battery charger to my Nikon D700. This is what happens when I “clean” my office. Searching a replacement on Amazon.com, I was faced with a simple decision: Go with the OEM Nikon MH-18a charger for $39.95 or roll the dice and go with a no-name charger for $4.41 with free shipping.
As you may have guessed from the name of this review, I went with the latter. Here's my review of this dirt cheap, third party battery charger that I bought for less than the price of a sandwich. The purpose of this review is simple: Do I wish I had a sandwich instead of this battery charger?
I bought this Bargaincell battery charger from the seller ATC LLC on Amazon.com. The package shipped free from Chicago, IL and I had it the next day after ordering. The package was delivered via normal US mail.
This battery charger is a modular system that's been designed for flexibility – there are two parts, the baseplate with the electrical prong and AC adapter input and the battery charging plate, which is fitted to your battery model. In this case, this charger is specifically for the Nikon EL-3E battery and Fuji NP-150 (which for the Fuji S5, based on the Nikon D200 model, which will also fit the Nikon EL-3).
It would actually be a great feature if you could buy just the plates to swap out for different cameras for people who shoot multiple kinds of batteries, but then again, these chargers are so cheap that it's a moot point.
Aside from the price, the fold-in prongs are probably the best feature about this battery charger. You know, aside from the fact that it actually charges my Nikon EL-EL3E battery instead of just catching fire.
The electrical plug folds completely flat into the body of the charger and eliminates the need for a cable like the Nikon MH-18a. This is not ideal if you need to access an outlet that's hard to reach, but for travel purposes and minimizing kit, it's a great feature.
This charger accepts 100V – 240V, so it's good pretty much everywhere, from the US to Europe to Asia.
Overall, the build quality of this charger is fine. The battery plate is secure and the whole thing feels surprisingly solid for $4 and change. The weakest point is the folding electrical prongs, as one might expect. The prongs feature a plastic hinge and it has a little wobble, but it does snap into active position positively and it feels plenty secure when the prongs are out.
Charging – Does This Thing Actually Work?
This is what you all really want to know – does this thing actually work? And the answer is that yes, it works just fine. Moreover, it works without catching on fire, which is pretty much all you can ask for at this price.
The unit features an LED indicator for the charging status – orange for ongoing charging and green for a completed charge, so you know when the battery is ready to go. The charger even features built-in over-charge protection. Or at least that's what Amazon.com's listing says.
Is this charger worth $4? Absolutely. I have no complaints at all and no regrets going cheap over the $40 Nikon MH-18a. In fact, I wish the Nikon charger had the folding plug of this charger (and of course the price).
Normally I'm all for buying the best OEM stuff – in fact, most of the time I'm a snob – but in the case of an accessory like a battery charger like this, it's hard not to recommend this $4 cheapie. This is true if you need to replace your main battery charger, but especially if you're looking to pick up something you can throw in your travel bag or keep at the office, in your car, etc.
No regrets about buying this cheap charger that's 1/8 the price of the OEM version (not even when I could have bought a sandwich with the money).
Where to Buy
You can buy this battery charger from Amazon with free shipping (nice perk):
- Surprisingly reliable no-name battery charger